Empowering The People: Deciphering Beuracracy

Many will say that our country is run by bureaucrats who do anything possible to make your life harder and then exploit that hardship by offering their service to make your life easier for ‘X’ amount of money. Aligning incentives is the first thing an HR consultant will recommend for fixing an operation. Aligning just means having the same incentives of “the owners” or “the people” whether they are of the management or the work force.

Let’s study the incentives that govern the simple process of approving the legal documents of starting a company for example. If the bureaucrat signs your paper, you benefit by the potential stream of income from that company while he gains nothing. He receives the same income for more work he has to do processing your request, he is exposed to the scrutiny of the auditing committee, and he might even be accused of bribery. If the bureaucrat disapproves or delays approving your letter, you lose potential gains but he gains by avoiding scrutiny.

In “game theory”, the economical science of predicting incentives and reactions would be called “zero-sum game”. In other words, if you gain he loses, and if he gains you lose. The problem is that he has more power than you, and he will always use it to his benefit: his gain, your loss or, in other words, he will not sign it. Since the incentive system is currently not aligned, bribery will be created to solve the problem, to reach “the equilibrium”, and balance it out.

The solution: Aligning incentives so that your gain becomes his gain and so that he legitimately gains as much as you do by approving the said letter. Your incentive is profit, if achieved it contributes to GDP, and to “the people” as a whole.  In other words, “the people’s” incentive is more profit. Now we need to tie that somehow and make it influence the bureaucrat’s incentives for financial gains.

We know that the “people’s profits” is positively influenced by the number of start-up businesses, which is in turn affected by the speed of starting up the business. If the bureaucrat’s income or salary increases in direct relation to how fast he approves the legal documents, then we would surely have aligned the incentives by motivating the bureaucrat to processes it faster. This is what is known as Merit-based pay;  you get paid based on your performance. We currently operate under a Step-based system which links getting paid to the amount of time spent in the organization which only serves to encourage the bureaucrat to be even more bureaucratic. The shift to Merit-based pay is essential.

For the Merit-based system to succeed, clear objectives have to be set, performance has to be accurately measured, and a clear ‘performance-compensation’ formula has to be identified and communicated. Performance could be measured against individual, team-based, or even organizational objectives through a variety of means such as surveys, interviews, or result assessments. Whichever technique is used, the most important factor is that the measurements are quantifiable, fair, and objective.

A strong system of checks and balances, in addition to the Judiciary Power’s control system,  will ensure the integrity of the system. With clear and efficient policies, inefficient layers and redundant cycles of approvals will be replaced with a leaner system providing each bureaucrat with the necessary objectives and, most importantly, the authority and tools to achieve them. And with that, we can be proud to state that our country is run by the type of  bureaucrats  who will do everything possible to make your life easier through the lawful services they provide.


About forwardegypt

Egypt: Ideas for empowering the people, creating wealth, and improving standards of living
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Empowering The People: Deciphering Beuracracy

  1. Mara says:

    I read through your available pages and congratulate you for taking the time and thought-energy required to come up with all this, some of it makes sense as an overall plan but your section on Empowering the People, Deciphering Bureaucracy…………ahem. Your bio says you are working in banking system…..noooothththing like the Egyptian bureaucracy system……..worlds apart…..sorry!

    Government employees paid to administer state bodies affecting the lives of the entire population should neither be driven by incentives nor hounded by audits – you are suggesting another form of secret service in the midst of government employees.

    Government office of all levels should hold status in the eyes of the employees themselves as well as those they serve – namely the public. That is not the case at the moment because most of them don’t even have papers or pens, filing cabinets, basic office equipment – I won’t even dream of computers! They work in filthy hovels where you wouldn’t want your clothes to touch the walls and are paid miserable wages necessitating the corruption that exists if they are to take home enough money to survive!

    Government employees need their roles defined, equipment – such as phones….! to enable them function and pay check at the end of the day that makes them independent of the public they serve on a daily basis. Simple!

    Proper and dignified working conditions, real meaningful satisfying work and proper pay = happy workers = 0 corruption necessary. Without incentives, merits or spying. Your suggestive incentive approach would just swing the system from no papers being signed to every paper being signed and maybe even a few manufactured! Sorry! Analysing the way companies work, eliminating the un-necessary and introducing time/cost saving methodology was a former occupation of mine.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s